Champion Windows Vs. Renewal by Andersen: Best Pick?

Champion Windows Vs. Renewal by Andersen Best Pick

Champion Windows Vs. Renewal by Andersen: Best Pick?

Champion Windows and Renewal by Andersen offer energy-efficient window replacement solutions. Champion specializes in vinyl, while Andersen prefers wood/fibrex composites.

Selecting the right company for window replacement requires considering various factors like material preferences, energy efficiency, and investment value. Champion Windows provides a robust vinyl selection known for its affordability and ease of maintenance. On the other hand, Renewal by Andersen is noted for its premium wood/fibrex composite windows that boast durability and a classic aesthetic.

Both companies offer a range of styles and customization options to fit different home designs and personal tastes. Customers can expect a warranty and professional installation services from either provider, making both Champion and Andersen reliable choices for upgrading your home’s windows. Assess your specific needs, budget, and the architectural style of your home to make the best decision between these two window replacement giants. Each company’s reputation for customer service and product quality plays a crucial role in the long-term satisfaction with your investment.

Company Overview

Deciding on the right windows for your home involves more than just choosing a style or color; it’s about selecting a company that stands behind its products with robust warranties, offers expert installation, and focuses on customer satisfaction. In this company overview, we take a focused look at two leading window providers: Champion Windows and Renewal by Andersen. Each company has made a significant mark in the industry, but their approaches, products, and services cater to different homeowner needs.

Champion Windows

Champion Windows has carved out a niche in the market as a direct-to-consumer provider known for its custom-manufactured windows. Pride in craftsmanship becomes evident when you experience the tailored fit and finish of their products. Founded in the mid-1950s, Champion has accumulated a wealth of experience that benefits homeowners through:

  • Energy efficiency: A focus on reducing utility bills through well-insulated window designs.
  • Wide product range: Offerings include not only windows but also sunrooms, doors, and sidings.
  • American-made: With manufacturing based in the United States, Champion supports local economies and ensures a stricter quality control.
  • Lifetime warranty: Champion’s confidence in their products is reflected in their lifetime guarantee, covering the frame, glass, hardware, and installation.

Champion Windows prides itself on full-service customer experience from free estimates to professional installation and aftercare.

Renewal By Andersen

Renewal by Andersen, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Andersen Corporation, represents a premier brand in window replacement. Since its inception in 1995, Renewal by Andersen has aimed to combine the legacy of its parent company with innovative approaches to window replacement. Key aspects of their service include:

Aspect Renewal by Andersen Advantage
Material Innovation Utilization of Fibrex material, which blends wood fiber with thermoplastic polymer for durability and insulation.
Customization Each window is custom-built with a plethora of design and style options tailored to homeowner preferences.
Energy Efficiency Energy Star partner, with products designed to meet strict energy efficiency guidelines set by the EPA.
Professional Installation Expert installation services by certified professionals, ensuring optimal performance and precision.
Environmental Responsibility Commitment to sustainable practices, including recycling of old windows and responsible sourcing of materials.

Renewal by Andersen combines the trustworthiness of a historically significant brand with cutting-edge window technology, focusing on a superior customer journey from consultation through to the completion of the installation.

Product Comparison

When it comes to choosing new windows for your home, you likely seek style, energy efficiency, durability, and robust warranties to ensure your investment stands the test of time. This product comparison will dissect the offerings from two prominent window manufacturers: Champion Windows and Renewal by Andersen. Both have solid reputations, but it’s the details that distinguish a good choice from a great one for your home improvement needs.

Window Styles

Understanding the available window styles is crucial in selecting the right fit for your home’s aesthetics and functionality. Champion Windows provides a broad assortment of styles, including double-hung, casement, sliding, picture, bay, bow, and garden windows. These options allow homeowners to maintain a consistent look or mix and match to create a unique appearance.

Conversely, Renewal by Andersen also boasts a versatile lineup with similar offerings—double-hung, casement, bay, bow, sliding, and more. What sets Andersen apart is their exclusive Fibrex material, combining the strength of wood with the low maintenance of vinyl.

Energy Efficiency

Energy efficiency is at the top of the list for eco-conscious homeowners and those looking to reduce utility bills. Champion Windows showcases their Comfort 365® glass, designed to provide superior thermal performance all year round. These windows meet Energy Star standards, ensuring they contribute to both energy savings and environmental sustainability.

In the same vein, Renewal by Andersen offers High-Performance™ Low-E4® glass, which is 56% more energy-efficient in summer and 47% more in winter compared to ordinary dual-pane glass. This focus on energy efficiency is testament to Andersen’s commitment to both eco-friendliness and cost-effective home temperature management.


The longevity of a window is determined by its durability under various climatic conditions. Champion Windows prides itself on their Vinyl construction, ensuring that the windows are resistant to corrosion, rotting, and peeling. This construction delivers low-maintenance and long-lasting windows suited for all types of weather.

On the other hand, Renewal by Andersen uses its proprietary Fibrex material that boasts the strength and insulating value of wood with the low maintenance features of vinyl. Fibrex is twice as strong as vinyl and designed to withstand extreme temperature fluctuations, which enhances the lifespan of the windows.


The confidence a company has in its product often reflects in its warranty. Champion Windows impresses with a Limited Lifetime Warranty that covers the frame, sash, glass, and other components. Additionally, the warranty is transferable to the next homeowner, adding potential value to your home should you decide to sell.

Renewal by Andersen steps up with a robust warranty package as well—most notably, a 20-year limited warranty on the glass and Fibrex material. Their warranties are also fully transferable, providing assurance to future owners and ensuring the lasting value of the investment.

Selecting the right windows involves weighing various factors—the design preferences, the need for energy savings, durability against harsh elements, and the assurance of a warranty. Whether Champion Windows or Renewal by Andersen, homeowners can rest assured that each brand brings competitive features to the table. A clear comparison based on your specific needs will light the path to a well-informed decision that enhances your home’s comfort, aesthetics, and overall value.

Customer Reviews

Welcome to the ‘Customer Reviews’ section, where real-world experiences shed light on the quality and service provided by Champion Windows and Renewal by Andersen. In the realm of home improvement, customer feedback is a pivotal factor influencing homeowner choices. Here, we analyze what customers are saying about these two prominent window brands to give you a clearer picture of what to expect from each.

Champion Windows

Champion Windows has garnered a mixed spectrum of reviews from consumers. Customers often highlight the affordability and versatility of their product ranges as compelling reasons for their choices. The company’s custom-manufacturing approach means every window fits perfectly, satisfying those with unique home designs.

On the flip side, a few reviews indicate room for improvement in customer service and post-installation support. Delays in service and difficulties in warranty claims have been points of contention for some homeowners. To provide a structured summary, here’s a snapshot of what customers are saying:

  • Praise for the cost-effectiveness and variety of window styles
  • Positive feedback for the custom fit and installation process
  • Critical remarks regarding response times for service requests
  • Occasional dissatisfaction with the handling of warranty issues

Renewal By Andersen

Renewal by Andersen, known for its robust and energy-efficient windows, has earned acclaim for product quality and the eco-friendliness of its materials. Clients often express satisfaction with the windows’ performance in enhancing home insulation and reducing energy costs.

Concerning customer service, Renewal by Andersen receives a mixture of reviews. While many celebrate the company’s attentiveness and professional installation, some have noted higher costs and pressures from sales tactics as detractors. Organized by key themes, the customer feedback stands as follows:

Pros Cons
  • High marks for energy efficiency and durability
  • Positive remarks on installation and workmanship
  • Mentions of premium pricing compared to competitors
  • Critiques of aggressive sales practices

Ultimately, perusing these customer reviews aids in not only gauging the products themselves but also in understanding the service ecosystem surrounding these brands. Remember, customer experiences can vary widely, and what might be a dealbreaker for one homeowner may not impact another’s decision.

Cost And Financing Options

Understanding the cost and available financing options is a crucial step when considering Champion Windows or Renewal by Andersen for your window replacement needs. Deciding on the right option can be an easier process with a clear breakdown of potential expenses and payment plans. In the sections below, we dive into the pricing strategies of these two prominent companies and examine the financing plans available to homeowners.


Pricing for both Champion Windows and Renewal by Andersen varies widely based on numerous factors such as the style of windows, material choices, and customizations. It’s essential to compare these factors side-by-side to assess which brand offers the better value for your specific requirements. Champion Windows often positions itself as a cost-effective solution while Renewal by Andersen is typically associated with a premium pricing model.

When looking at Champion Windows, homeowners can expect:

  • Competitive pricing that challenges the rest of the market.
  • A price-range that caters to various budgets without sacrificing quality.
  • Options for energy-efficient windows that can lead to cost savings over time.

Alternatively, Renewal by Andersen offers:

  • Custom-crafted windows which can lead to higher upfront costs.
  • High-end materials such as Fibrex, contributing to the brand’s premium pricing.
  • Long-term savings due to their excellent energy efficiency and durability.

Financing Plans

To accommodate the budgeting needs of homeowners, both Champion Windows and Renewal by Andersen provide various financing avenues. This flexibility allows for manageable payments over time, making the investment in high-quality windows less daunting.

Champion Windows offers financing options that include:

  • Customizable payment plans with competitive interest rates.
  • Opportunities to defer payments or opt for reduced interest promotional periods.
  • Quick and efficient application process for immediate credit decisions.

Renewal by Andersen counters with:

  • Exclusive financing deals depending on seasonal promotions.
  • Flexible payment terms to fit various financial scenarios.
  • In-house financing that can make the process more straightforward and convenient.

To summarize, the cost of Champion Windows tends to cater to a broader market by offering competitive yet reasonable pricing, whereas Renewal by Andersen focuses on a premium niche with its high-quality, customizable options. Financing plans for both companies reflect their understanding of consumer needs, providing multiple avenues to ensure that customers can make comfortable investments in their home’s future.

Frequently Asked Questions For Champion Windows Vs. Renewal By Andersen

Are Champion Windows Good?

Champion Windows are reputable for their durability and energy efficiency. Customers often praise their quality, warranty, and the company’s customer service.

Who Makes The Best Replacement Windows On The Market?

The best replacement windows typically come from Pella, Andersen, and Milgard, known for their quality, durability, and energy efficiency. Each brand has its own unique features catering to different preferences and budgets.

Why Is Champion Windows So Expensive?

Champion Windows tend to be expensive due to their high-quality materials, energy-efficient design, custom manufacturing, and inclusive lifetime warranty on their products. Their pricing reflects the long-term value and performance homeowners seek.

Is Window World Better Than Champion Windows?

Window World and Champion Windows offer unique benefits, making them both reputable choices. Preference often depends on specific needs, local service quality, and budget considerations. It’s advisable to compare warranties, materials, and customer feedback for the best decision.


Deciding between Champion Windows and Renewal by Andersen depends on your needs. Both offer quality and durability, catering to different preferences and budgets. Assess your requirements, consult with experts, and choose the brand that aligns with your home improvement goals.

Your ideal windows await.

Leave a Reply