Bar Keepers Friend vs Bon Ami: An In-Depth Comparison

Bar Keepers Friend vs Bon Ami An In-Depth Comparison

Bar Keepers Friend vs Bon Ami: An In-Depth Comparison


When it comes to keeping our homes spick and span, the choice of cleaning products can make a significant difference. Two popular cleaning products that often find themselves in the battle of the cleansers are Barkeepers Friend and Bon Ami. Both these products have a strong reputation for their cleaning abilities, but they are not created equal. In this article, we will break down the differences between Barkeepers Friend and Bon Ami, helping you decide which one is the right fit for your cleaning needs.

What Is Barkeepers Friend?

Barkeepers Friend is a household cleaner that has been trusted for over a century. It is known for its ability to tackle tough stains, rust, and mineral deposits on various surfaces.

What Is Bon Ami?

Bon Ami, on the other hand, is another renowned household cleaner that has been around for more than a century as well. It is recognized for its gentle abrasive action that effectively cleans without scratching.

Ingredients Comparison

Barkeepers Friend Ingredients

Barkeepers Friend primarily contains oxalic acid, which is a powerful cleaner and rust remover. It also contains surfactants that help in breaking down grease and grime.

Bon Ami Ingredients

Bon Ami, on the contrary, uses a simpler formula. Its primary ingredient is natural limestone, which acts as a gentle abrasive. It also contains biodegradable detergents, making it an eco-friendly choice.

Cleaning Power

Barkeepers Friend’s Cleaning Power

Barkeepers Friend excels at tackling stubborn stains, rust, and hard water deposits. It is particularly effective on stainless steel, porcelain, and ceramic surfaces. Its powerful oxalic acid formula ensures that it can remove even the toughest stains with ease.

Bon Ami’s Cleaning Power

Bon Ami’s strength lies in its ability to provide effective cleaning without scratching delicate surfaces. It is safe to use on glass, porcelain, and even on non-stick cookware. While it may not be as potent as Barkeepers Friend for heavy-duty cleaning, it is an excellent choice for everyday cleaning tasks.

Safety and Environmental Impact

Barkeepers Friend’s Safety and Environmental Impact

Barkeepers Friend's Safety and Environmental Impact

Barkeepers Friend, with its strong cleaning agents, should be used with caution. It is essential to follow the usage instructions carefully and ensure proper ventilation when using this product. While it is effective, it may not be the best choice for those looking for eco-friendly options.

Bon Ami’s Safety and Environmental Impact

Bon Ami is a safer and more environmentally friendly option. Its natural ingredients make it biodegradable, and it does not contain harmful chemicals. This makes it an ideal choice for individuals who prioritize safety and sustainability.

Price Comparison

Barkeepers Friend’s Price

Barkeepers Friend is often more affordable compared to Bon Ami. It offers a budget-friendly option for those looking to clean their homes effectively without breaking the bank.

Bon Ami’s Price

Bon Ami, while slightly pricier than Barkeepers Friend, still provides good value for its cleaning performance. Its eco-friendly attributes may justify the higher price point for environmentally conscious consumers.


In the battle of the cleansers, both Barkeepers Friend and Bon Ami have their strengths and weaknesses. Barkeepers Friend is a potent cleaner, ideal for tackling tough stains and rust. On the other hand, Bon Ami offers a more eco-friendly and gentler approach to cleaning without scratching delicate surfaces. Your choice ultimately depends on your cleaning needs and priorities.

So, whether you opt for the powerful cleaning action of Barkeepers Friend or the eco-friendly and gentle cleaning of Bon Ami, remember that both have stood the test of time and can help you maintain a clean and sparkling home.


Can I use Barkeepers Friend on my glass stovetop?

Yes, Barkeepers Friend is safe to use on glass stovetops. It can effectively remove stains and burnt-on residue.

Is Bon Ami safe for use on granite countertops?

Yes, Bon Ami is safe for use on granite countertops. Its gentle abrasive action won’t damage the surface.

Are there any safety precautions I should take when using Barkeepers Friend?

Yes, always wear gloves and ensure proper ventilation when using Barkeepers Friend. Avoid contact with eyes and follow the usage instructions.

Is Bon Ami vegan and cruelty-free?

Yes, Bon Ami is both vegan and cruelty-free, making it a conscious choice for animal lovers.

Leave a Reply