Stella Cherry Tree vs Bing Cherry Tree: A Gardener’s Dilemma

Stella Cherry Tree vs Bing Cherry Tree A Gardener's Dilemma

Stella Cherry Tree vs Bing Cherry Tree: A Gardener’s Dilemma


When it comes to adding fruit-bearing trees to your garden, the choice between Stella Cherry Trees and Bing Cherry Trees can be a delightful yet perplexing dilemma. In this article, we’ll explore the characteristics, pros and cons, and practical tips for cultivating these two cherry tree varieties. By the end, you’ll have a clearer picture of which tree aligns best with your gardening goals.

Characteristics of Stella Cherry Tree

Growth Habit and Size

Stella Cherry Trees are known for their compact size, making them suitable for smaller gardens. They typically reach a height of 10 to 15 feet, providing an attractive and manageable addition to your landscape.

Fruiting Season

One of the standout features of Stella Cherry Trees is their early fruiting season. Gardeners can anticipate a bountiful harvest in early summer, a delightful advantage for those eager to enjoy fresh cherries sooner in the season.

Fruit Characteristics

Stella cherries are medium-sized with a sweet flavor, making them perfect for fresh consumption or culinary uses. The vibrant red color of the fruit adds aesthetic appeal to your garden.

Soil and Climate Preferences

Stella Cherry Trees thrive in well-drained soil with a slightly acidic to neutral pH. They are also resilient in various climates, adapting well to both warm and cold regions.

Characteristics of Bing Cherry Tree

Characteristics of Bing Cherry Tree

Growth Habit and Size

In contrast, Bing Cherry Trees are known for their larger size, often reaching 25 feet or more. This makes them suitable for more spacious landscapes where their grandeur can be fully appreciated.

Fruiting Season

Bing cherries follow a later fruiting season, typically in late spring to early summer. Patience is key with these trees, but the reward is a robust harvest of delicious, dark red cherries.

Fruit Characteristics

Bing cherries are renowned for their sweet and succulent taste. The deep red, almost mahogany, hue of the fruit adds a touch of elegance to the tree and your garden.

Soil and Climate Preferences

Bing Cherry Trees prefer well-drained soil and are more sensitive to winter chill hours, making them better suited for regions with colder winters.

Pros and Cons of Stella Cherry Tree

Advantages for Gardeners

Stella Cherry Trees are a favorite among gardeners for their compact size, early fruiting, and adaptability to various climates. They are an excellent choice for urban gardens or those with limited space.

Potential Drawbacks

However, it’s essential to note that Stella cherries may not store as well as some other varieties, and their flavor profile might not suit every palate.

Pros and Cons of Bing Cherry Tree

Advantages for Gardeners

Bing Cherry Trees, on the other hand, are prized for their majestic presence, late spring harvest, and the exceptional quality of their cherries. They make a statement in larger gardens and orchards.

Potential Drawbacks

The main consideration with Bing cherries is their size, which may not be suitable for all landscapes. Additionally, the later fruiting season requires more patience from gardeners.

Best Uses in Landscaping

Ornamental Value

Stella Cherry Trees contribute to the visual appeal of your garden with their compact size and early blooms. They are an ideal choice if you want a cherry tree that doubles as a decorative element.

Edible Fruit Production

Both Stella and Bing Cherry Trees excel in producing delicious fruit. The choice between them depends on your preferences, available space, and the desired timing of your cherry harvest.

Versatility in Different Climates

Stella and Bing Cherry Trees showcase versatility in adapting to different climates, but gardeners should consider the specific requirements of each variety when selecting the best fit for their region.

Planting and Care Tips

Soil Preparation

Before planting either variety, ensure the soil is well-drained and has the appropriate pH level. Amending the soil with organic matter can enhance the tree’s overall health.

Watering and Fertilization

Cherry trees benefit from consistent watering, especially during dry periods. A balanced fertilizer applied in early spring helps promote healthy growth and fruit development.

Pruning Guidelines

Regular pruning is essential to maintain the shape and size of the trees, as well as to encourage air circulation. Prune during the dormant season to avoid stress on the tree.

Common Pest and Disease Management

Both Stella and Bing Cherry Trees are susceptible to certain pests and diseases. Implementing preventative measures, such as regular inspections and proper care, can minimize these issues.

Popular Varieties of Each

Notable Stella Cherry Tree Varieties

  1. Stella Sweet Cherry
  2. Lapins Cherry
  3. Compact Stella Cherry

Notable Bing Cherry Tree Varieties

  1. Bing Sweet Cherry
  2. Black Tartarian Cherry
  3. Rainier Cherry

Success Stories from Gardeners

Real-World Experiences with Stella Cherry Tree

Gardeners across various climates have shared success stories with Stella Cherry Trees, praising their adaptability and reliable fruiting.

Real-World Experiences with Bing Cherry Tree

Bing Cherry Trees have been celebrated for their impressive stature and the joy of a late spring harvest, making them a cherished addition to many orchards.

Customer Reviews and Ratings

Online Feedback from Gardening Communities

Positive reviews highlight the tastiness of Stella cherries and the convenience of having a fruit-bearing tree in smaller spaces. Bing cherries receive acclaim for their size, flavor, and ornamental value.

Ratings and Recommendations

Stella and Bing Cherry Trees consistently receive high ratings for their overall performance and fruit quality. Recommendations emphasize proper care and site selection for optimal results.


In the choice between Stella Cherry Trees and Bing Cherry Trees, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Consider your garden size, climate, and preferences when making this decision. Whether you opt for the compact elegance of Stella or the grandeur of Bing, both trees offer a delightful cherry-growing experience for gardeners.


Can Stella and Bing Cherry Trees be cross-pollinated?

Yes, cross-pollination is beneficial for both varieties, enhancing fruit production.

How do I know if my cherry trees need more water?

Monitor soil moisture and water when the top inch of soil feels dry, especially during dry spells.

Are there any dwarf varieties of Stella and Bing Cherry Trees?

Yes, Compact Stella is a dwarf variety that fits well in smaller gardens.

What is the typical lifespan of these cherry tree varieties?

With proper care, Stella and Bing Cherry Trees can live for 15 to 20 years or more.

Can I grow Stella and Bing Cherry Trees in containers?

While possible, it’s recommended to plant them in the ground for better growth and longevity.

Leave a Reply